Pay Your Bill

First Insurance Services makes it easy for you to pay you bill online or by phone.Retirement - pay your bill online

Miscellaneous - encompass

To make you payment online...

  • Click on the Encompass Insurance logo above
  • Scroll down to access your account on the right side of the page
  • You will need the following: Policy number, Zip code (on the policy) and Checking or Credit Card information.

To make your payment by phone call 1-866-430-2916


Miscellaneous - Erie

To make your payment online...

  • Click on the Erie Insurance Group logo above
  • On the right side of the page Is Your Bill Due?
  • Select pay online
  • You will need the following: Policy Number, Name and Address on policy, Banking account routing and account information.

To make your payment by phone call 1-800-387-1492


Miscellaneous - Safeco

To make your payment online...

  • Click on the SAFECO insurance logo above
  • Account Services 1st column on left
  • You can register to pay bills and review account online
  • You will need your policy number

To make your payment by phone call 1-800-332-3226


Miscellaneous - Progressive

To make your payment online...

  • Click on the Progressive logo above
  • In the upper right hand corner select Register to pay or review policy online.
  • You will need your policy number

To make your payment by phone call 1-800-925-2886


Miscellaneous - State Auto

To make your payment online...

  • Click on the State Auto logo above
  • Scroll down to box on left hand side Your Account - pay your bill
  • You will need: Your policy number, zip code on the policy, as well as information for payment method.

To make your payment by phone call 1-800-444-9950 Ext. 5118